|
Dial
up
|
ISDN |
Satellite
|
DSL |
Cable |
NetPort |
An email
(5 KB) |
1 sec. |
1 sec. |
1 sec. |
1 sec. |
1 sec. |
1 sec. |
A
basic web
page
(25 KB) |
10 sec. |
5 sec. |
1 sec. |
1 sec. |
1 sec. |
1 sec. |
A complex
web page
(500 KB) |
90 sec. |
40 sec. |
15 sec. |
7 sec. |
5 sec. |
4 sec. |
One
five-
minute song
(5 MB) |
15 min. |
8 min.
|
2 min. |
1 min.
|
50 sec. |
40 sec. |
One
movie preview
(30 MB) |
80 min.
|
40 min.
|
15 min.
|
7 min.
|
6 min.
|
4 min.
|
One
two-
hour movie
(500 MB) |
20 hrs. |
10 hrs. |
4 hrs. |
2 hrs. |
90 min. |
70 min. |
Connection Comparisons
If you access the Internet from
home, you've probably been using what's known
as a dial up connection; in other words, you dial
a telephone number on your computer, hear a series
of weird sounds, and end up surfing the Internet
about a minute later. Sometimes you get busy signals,
or the connection speed suddenly drops to a snail's
pace, or somebody in the house picks up the phone
and cuts your connection right in the middle of
an important download. Depending on your service
provider, you might even have to carefully limit
the amount of time you spend online, or else pay
extra hourly fees.
Dialup is the conventional way of getting on-line
by using a phone line to transfer data to and
from your computer with a modem. A dialup modem
can reach speeds of up to 56kbps. Most people
also have a second phone line in their home or
office to assure there is always a line available
to access the Internet. With the dial up modem
there are delay times of 150-200 milliseconds.
A dialup account usually has a monthly cost of
$20-$25 plus the cost of a second phone line.
Cable Modem:
The main disadvantage of cable is that the speed
of the system is dependent on the number of people
who are online at the same time; if many people
in your neighborhood are using their cable modems
at once, your connection speed may drop considerably.
Cable modem performance can undergo significant
fluctuations; at its best, it's the fastest of
all consumer-level broadband services, but at
its worst, it's almost as slow as a dial up service.
DSL:
With DSL (Digital Subscriber Line), data is transferred
digitally to and from your computer over a phone
line. It can reach speeds of up to 1500k with
delay times of less than 50 milliseconds. DSL
is very dependent on the distance of your home
or office from the phone company's central office.
If your home or office is located too far away
from this office then you will not be able to
receive DSL. DSL fees for speeds equivalent to
NetPort can be $50 or more per month and must
also purchase the DSL modem. The main disadvantage
of DSL is that its speed is dependent on your
physical distance from the phone company's nearest
central switch (known as a Central Office); the
farther you are from the switch, the slower your
average connection speed will be. Your home or
business will have to pass a loop qualification
test run by your phone company before you can
have DSL installed. Also, DSL setup can be complex;
in many cases, separate visits from the broadband
provider and your phone company will be required
Satellite:
Using a satellite connection is another way to
access the Internet. The satellite uses a dish
to transfer data to and from your computer. A
satellite connection can reach speeds of up to
600k with the delay time of 400-500 milliseconds.
The satellite connection is an extremely expensive
way to get onto the Internet. There are expensive
set up fees, and equipment that must be purchased
by the customer. These costs can reach the thousand-dollar
range. On a monthly basis it can costs between
$50-$100.
There are many downsides to using satellite. The
performance of a satellite broadband connection
can be degraded by bad weather, local interference,
or a misaligned dish. Also, because of the way
the satellite data transfer works, satellite service
is not well suited to applications that require
constant transmission of small data packets; these
include online gaming, web page hosting, video
conferencing, and multiple small file downloads.
Wireless:
Wireless broadband (also known as fixed wireless
to distinguish it from the mobile wireless system
used by some pagers and mobile phones) is a new
technology that uses an antenna placed on or in
your building to send and receive data. The data
is transmitted to and from your building via your
city's wireless network, which consists of antenna
towers placed three to five miles apart. If you
can get wireless, you're getting an excellent
broadband connection. The connection speed is
not limited by your distance from the wireless
antenna or by the number of wireless users in
your area. Wireless' speed is currently comparable
to ADSL; however, the theoretical maximum is much
higher, so you can expect the speed of wireless
connections to increase in coming years. Wireless
is also an always-on connection that doesn't tie
up your phone line.
|